How to Tell the Difference Between Sciatica and Hamstring Pain?

How to Tell the Difference Between Sciatica and Hamstring Pain?
Picture of Dr. Peter Hinz
Dr. Peter Hinz

Chiropractic Doctor

How to Tell the Difference Between Sciatica and Hamstring Pain?

Call Now

615-503-9900

Categories

Categories

Table of Contents

Share this article:

Most hamstring injuries will be centralized in that area of the body, while sciatica can send shooting pain and numbness from the hip all the way to the toes.

Sciatica and hamstring pain can sometimes be challenging to differentiate from one another as they share many of the same symptoms. 

Sciatica is a condition caused by compression or irritation of the sciatic nerve, which runs down through your lower back and into each leg. On the other hand, hamstring pain is usually caused by tightness in this group of muscles located at the back of your thigh. 

Here are some tips on how to tell the difference between these two conditions so you can treat them properly.

The Differences

Not sure what kind of problem you have on your hands? Our list can help you figure it out.

Location of the Discomfort 

The most apparent difference between sciatica and hamstring pain is the location of the discomfort. 

Sciatica typically originates in the lower back or buttocks and radiates down one leg. On the other hand, hamstring pain will be centralized in that area of the body without sending shooting pains further away.

The Kind of Pain

When it comes to the type of pain, sciatica is characterized by a burning or tingling sensation all throughout the path of the nerve, while hamstring pain is generally more localized and sharp. 

Sciatica can also cause numbness along its course but typically won’t cause weakness in your legs. Hamstring injuries can sometimes result in muscle weakness.

Does It Radiate?

Another key difference is the radiation of the pain. Sciatica can send shooting pains and numbness from the hip to the toes, while hamstring pain will typically remain localized in your upper leg.

Does Moving Cause Discomfort?

Regarding movement-related pain, sciatica tends to worsen after sitting for an extended period or with specific movements like bending forward. If the pain worsens when you move your leg and hip in certain directions, it’s likely a hamstring injury.

Your Age

Age can also help differentiate between sciatica and hamstring pain. Sciatica is more common in people over 40, while hamstring strains are more common in younger people that engage in high-impact activities or sports.

Causes

Consider the cause of the pain, as this can help determine which condition you may be suffering from. Sciatica is often caused by something like a herniated disc or spinal stenosis, while hamstring pain is often caused by muscle strain or injury.

What Does It Feel Like to Pull a Hammy?

If you’ve never pulled a muscle, this is how it feels to have a muscle injury. Common symptoms of a hamstring strain include sudden pain in the back of the leg, tenderness or soreness in the muscle, and difficulty moving your leg (especially when bending it). 

Additionally, you may experience swelling and bruising around the area and tightness or spasms in the muscle. Swelling almost always means there is some time of injury. 

Are you currently dealing with these issues? Seek medical attention as soon as possible.  Treating a hamstring strain correctly from the start can help reduce the risk of further injury or re-injury.

Hamstring Issues – Causes

Tight hamstrings are often caused by prolonged sitting, improper stretching, or weak muscles.  To prevent hamstring strain, maintain flexibility in the muscle and perform regular stretches before and after exercise. Exercises such as leg lifts can help strengthen the muscle and reduce the risk of injury.

Tips on Identification

Identifying tight hamstrings can be difficult as the symptoms can be similar to other conditions, such as sciatica. 

To determine if you are suffering from this particular problem, pay attention to your body and look out for any signs or symptoms of discomfort in the area. Stretching tests can also help identify if your hamstring is tight. 

Fixing the Problem

The most important step in getting hamstring strains fixed is to seek professional care and advice. 

Your doctor can help diagnose the condition and provide an appropriate treatment plan, including rest, ice, compression, physical therapy, or medication. 

Additionally, your doctor may recommend exercises to improve the flexibility and strength of your muscles to prevent future injuries.

Recovery

The length of time it takes to recover from hamstring tightness will vary depending on the severity of the injury. Generally, mild cases can take around two weeks to heal, while more severe cases may take several months.

Home Stretches for Faster Recovery

Don’t rely on medications to fix your problems. Keeping blood flowing to your muscles and joints can help accelerate the healing process. Some of these will work for you, and some won’t. Try all of them for one set each to get an idea of how it feels, then increase the sets as you feel more comfortable.

  • Standing Stretch – To perform this stretch, stand with feet shoulder-width apart and gradually bend forward at the hips until you feel a slight pull in the back of your legs.
  • Seated forward bend stretch – Sit on the floor with your legs straight ahead. Slowly bend forward at the hips and reach towards your toes.
  • Foam rolling – Foam rolling is an excellent way to help relieve tightness in the hamstrings. Place a foam roller behind your thighs and press your body weight down onto it. Roll back and forth slowly for 1 minute while breathing deeply.
  • Laying stretch – This stretch is performed while lying down on your back. Bend one knee up towards your chest and use a belt or towel to loop around the ball of your foot. Gently pull the leg towards yourself until you feel a slight stretching sensation in the hamstring. 
  • Downward facing dog pose – This pose is an excellent way to stretch the entire back of your body, including your hamstrings. Start in a standing position and then slowly lower your chest and hips towards the ground while keeping your knees slightly bent. Reach up with both hands and press into the ground until you feel a gentle stretching sensation throughout the hamstrings.
  • Cross-legged forward bend – Sit on the floor with one leg crossed over the other and slowly bend forward at the hips. Reach towards your toes as far as you can without straining, and hold for 30 seconds before returning to starting position.
  • Ball stretch – Sit on a ball and slowly roll forward while keeping your back straight. Reach your hands out in front of you.
  • Supine hamstring stretch – This stretch is performed while lying down flat on your back. Place a belt or towel around the arch of one foot and gently pull it towards your chest until you feel a stretching sensation in the back of your leg.
  • Lizard Pose – This yoga pose is an excellent way to stretch the entire back side of your body, including your hamstrings. Start in a standing position and then lower one knee to the ground. Reach up with both hands and press into the ground until you feel a gentle stretching sensation throughout the back of your legs.
  • Pigeon Pose – Start in a standing position and then lower one knee to the ground. Reach up with both hands and press into the ground until you feel a gentle stretching sensation throughout the back of your legs.

What Is Sciatica and Why Does It Hurt So Much?

Sciatica stems from the sciatic nerve. It is a condition that causes pain in the lower back and buttock area that radiates down the back of your leg. 

The discomfort can fluctuate from mild to severe and is usually caused by an irritation or compression of the sciatic nerve. Various issues, including herniated discs, spinal stenosis, and piriformis syndrome, can cause sciatica.

While sciatica can be excruciating and uncomfortable, it is usually not severe. It can often be managed with lifestyle modifications or therapies such as physical therapy, massage, hot/cold compressions, and exercise.

Treatment for Sciatica

Treatment options for sciatica vary depending on the underlying cause of the condition. Generally, treatment involves lifestyle modifications such as exercise, physical therapy, and rest. 

Hot/cold compresses and massage can also provide relief from the pain associated with sciatica.

Stretches to Ease Nerve Pain

While there is no cure for sciatica, it can be efficiently managed with lifestyle modifications such as exercise, physical therapy, and rest. Stretches targeted at the buttocks and leg muscles can help alleviate pain caused by sciatica.

  • Seated glute stretch – This stretch is performed while seated in a chair. Cross one leg over the other and sit up tall with your spine straight. Place one hand behind you for support, and then use the opposite arm to gently pull your knee towards your chest until you feel a gentle stretching sensation in the buttocks.
  • Sitting spinal stretch – Do this one while seated on the floor. Cross one leg over the other and sit up tall with your spine straight. Clasp both hands behind you and then gently lean back as far as possible until you feel a gentle stretching sensation in your lower back.
  • Basic seated stretch – Sit on the floor. Cross one leg over the other and sit up tall with your spine straight. Place one hand behind you for support, and then use the opposite arm to gently pull your knee towards your chest until you feel a gentle stretching sensation in your lower back.
  • Figure 4 stretch – Lie down. Place your right ankle over your left thigh so that you look like a figure 4 shape. Gently press down on your right knee and hold this position for 1-2 minutes while breathing deeply. You should feel a gentle stretching sensation in the buttocks and hip area. Repeat this stretch on the opposite side.
  • Knee to the opposite shoulder – While lying down, bring your right knee up towards your chest and place your right hand around the back of your thigh or calf. Gently pull your leg towards the opposite shoulder until you feel a gentle stretching sensation in your buttocks and hip area.
  • Forward pigeon pose – This stretch is performed while on the floor in a seated position. Move your right leg forward and place your shin parallel to the front of your mat. Press down on your right knee until you feel a gentle stretching sensation in your buttocks and hip area. Then do the opposite side.
  • Standing hamstring stretch – While standing, place your right foot on a raised platform such as a chair or low table. Press down on your right leg until you feel a gentle stretching sensation in your hamstring muscle. Switch sides.
  • Standing piriformis stretch – Cross your right leg over the left while standing and place your right foot in front of your left thigh. Gently press down on your right hip until you feel a gentle stretching sensation in the buttocks area. Do the opposite side.
  • Scissor hamstring stretch – Lie down. Place your right leg out straight, and then bring your left knee up towards your chest. Press down on both legs until you feel a gentle stretching sensation in the hamstring muscles. Switch sides.

Remember to perform all of these stretches slowly and gently. If you feel sharp pain or discomfort at any point, stop immediately and consult with a physiotherapist or healthcare professional before continuing.

FAQ

How to tell the difference between tight hamstring and sciatica?

A good way to tell the difference between tight hamstring and sciatica is by performing stretches that target different areas of the body. Sciatica can cause pain in the buttocks and hip area, while a tight hamstring typically causes discomfort in the lower leg. 

Additionally, sciatica is often accompanied by numbness or tingling sensations in the legs. If the pain persists despite stretching, it may be time to consult a healthcare provider for further evaluation.

Does sciatica feel like a tight hamstring?

Not necessarily. A tight hamstring typically causes discomfort on the backside of the thigh.

How do you relieve sciatic pain in your hamstring?

Stretching can help to relieve sciatic pain in the hamstring. Some of the best stretches for sciatica include the ones we listed above. Make sure to perform all of these stretches slowly and gently.

How do I know if I have sciatica or muscle pain?

Some telltale signs of sciatica can help you differentiate it from muscle pain. Sciatica typically causes a burning or radiating pain in the buttocks and hip area, while a tight muscle will be localized.

Sciatica hamstring pain symptoms

The most common symptom of sciatica hamstring pain is a burning or radiating sensation in the buttocks and hip area. Additionally, this type of pain may be accompanied by numbness or tingling sensations in the legs.

Sciatica hamstring pain relief

Stretching can help to relieve sciatica hamstring pain. You can also try taking NSAIDS and practicing the RICE technique.

Related posts

Spinal manipulation
pete

Who to See For Spinal Decompression?

Healthcare professionals, such as orthopedic specialists, neurosurgeons, chiropractors, physical therapists and pain management specialists, are trained to perform non-surgical spinal decompression therapy on patients as

Read More »